I had read The Power and the Glory by Graham Greene a couple of times - and enjoyed it. So as I was cleaning out more books to donate as I downsize I uncovered several books by Greene that I had not read. I decided to give The Heart of the Matter a go.
In terms of plotting and the writing, it is quite good. Graham is a gifted writer.
But in terms of the main character's struggle with being a good "Catholic," I think it falls short. Scobie's moral rationalizing and confusion, and shallow religious thinking, seem to foreshadow the path of so many weak Catholics in the years since who will settle for pleasure and desire over faith.
Scobie commits adultery, he commits sacrilege, he gets caught up in illegal activities even though he is a police official, his words and actions lead to a murder, and then he commits suicide. Oh, along the way he seems to be struggling with his desires and selfishness in light of his faith, but he gives in to those desires again and again. He is not the only one harmed by his actions. He wants to keep his wife and mistress "happy," but in the end he hurts and damages them both, and a loyal servant ends up dead.
There are no winners in this book.
As he dies, his last words are "Dear God, I love ...." Is Graham trying to give us hope that Scobie repented at the last minute? Is he guilty of offering his readers what so many Hollywood religious movies did and do - wallow in sin, and then give a little moral twist at the end to make it all okay?
Knowing that Graham at the time he wrote this book had deserted his wife and family for a mistress, is the moral confusion in the book reflecting his own moral confusion and attempted self-justification?
As I read about Scobie's descent, I thought of Frodo from The Lord of the Rings!
In both cases, earlier actions led to the moment when they could fall. In Scobie's case, his adultery led to him lying, to being blackmailed, his illegal actions, his sacrilege, death of his loyal servant, and his own death. In Frodo's case, his good action, his mercy toward Gollum earlier in the epic, saved him at the end. Frodo is about to fall, to embrace the ring and its evil, when Gollum fights him, bites off his finger, and falls into Mt. Doom with the ring, completing Frodo's mission. If Frodo had not shown mercy earlier, Gollum would not have been there at the key moment, and Frodo would have been lost.
As for Greene, I have two more of his novels that I have not yet read. He is a good writer, but the flawed morality of The Heart of the Matter left a bad taste in my mouth, so I'm going to read a good Catholic mystery to clear my palate.
Pax et bonum