On the front cover there was the declaration that it is "The Definitive Biography".
I checked it out, wanting to know more about our relatively new Pope, who was elected May 8, 2025.
The book does give some background about him and his beliefs, and some details about his election, with some plausible speculation about the factors that helped to lead to his surprise election. But it is hardly a "definitive" biography. The coverage of his life prior to his election seemed less than comprehensive.
Indeed, the book reads like something that was quickly thrown together, perhaps of pieces written separately then just combined. Kengor keeps repeating explanations and comments as if introducing them in separate articles. There's even a glaring error of referring to pro-abortion politicians like Senator Dick Durbin as pro-life! And the book seemed padded with asides about other figures.
It needed some editing.
Moreover, Kengor spends an inordinate amount of time criticizing Pope Francis. Given some of the people he repeatedly cites - and who endorsed the book - it quickly became clear that he is of the more conservative wing of Catholicism. Yes, Pope Francis had issues and made some poor decisions, but there was no need to keep bringing them up again and again.
The title should have been a dead giveaway of the nature of the book and Kengor's leanings.
It's not a bad book, just flawed and unbalanced. I think the "definitive biography" is yet to be written.
Pax et bonum


