Last night I attended a concert by John McCutcheon. That man is an incredibly talented performer. He skillfully played multiple instruments, his vocals were wonderful, as were his humorous stories and banter. I also appreciated his songwriting.
It was a great concert.
As part of it he sang a song he and Tom Paxton co-authored - the two have been creating together for a while and even released two joint albums. The song was "Everything." In it they discuss what Jesus had to say about homosexuality. Every time they'd get to something like "He said," McCutcheon played a musical fill. In other words, Jesus said nothing.
Each time he played that little musical joke the largely progressive audience chuckled and laughed. They got the point: The implication being that since Jesus didn't say anything, it was okay.
As I sat there, I thought, Jesus didn't say anything about pedophilia or bestiality. Would that imply He accepted them as well?
Of course, the song really is just glib and superficial - and misleading.
First, to be clear, there is a difference between homosexuality, a disordered condition, and homosexual acts, which are inherently immoral.
Jesus was Jewish. He was preaching to a First Century largely Jewish audience. In that culture at the time homosexuality was not a topic they would discuss or question Him about. It was considered a settled matter: Homosexual acts were condemned and viewed as abhorrent. Under Jewish law, such an act could potentially lead to execution.
Now if Jesus had brought it up to challenge the law or its interpretation - as he did about other practices and laws - that would have been different. But as McCutcheon and Paxton pointed out, He said nothing.
However, Jesus did say in Matthew 5: 17-19:
“Do not think that I have come to abolish the law or the prophets. I have come not to abolish but to fulfill.
Amen, I say to you, until heaven and earth pass away, not the smallest letter or the smallest part of a letter will pass from the law, until all things have taken place.
Therefore, whoever breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do so will be called least in the kingdom of heaven. But whoever obeys and teaches these commandments will be called greatest in the kingdom of heaven."
And, of course, Jesus defended marriage as between a man and woman.
So rather than interpreting His silence on the issue as acceptance of homosexual acts, what makes more sense would be to say that He accepted the condemnation of them.
A side observation.
In his stories and songs there was a clear Catholic influence. He mentions nuns, Catholic churches and schools, sang a humorous song about the Pope, and another song about the Camino, which he says he intends to walk. So, I wondered if he might be a Catholic. I looked up his bio at a couple of sites. They generally said something like he was raised in a Catholic family. In my experience, that means the person was a Catholic but no longer practices. Then I came across one site that said he was raised in a Catholic family but has been a Quaker for many years.
Makes sense.
Pax et bonum
No comments:
Post a Comment